Saturday, January 31, 2015
Innocent Victim: A good documentary that could have been much better
I knew little about Aaron Swartz, the subject of the recent documentary The Internet's Own Boy, and learned a lot from the movie, enough to agree with the highly tendentious filmmaker that Swartz was without question a victim of the vindictive and self-aggrandizing acts of the Obama administration and in particular of a zealous prosecutor, that he was extremely smart and thoughtful, a rare combination of programming genius and brilliant articulation of socio-political beliefs, that his suicide was tragic and needless and caused by the relentless prosecution and not by some long-standing depression or other psychological imbalance. The message is valuable and should make all of us - especially supporters of the Obama administration, which I am - very wary and aware. Swartz's ends were noble if, in my view, in some cases misguided: the act that drew the criminal prosecution was his hacking into the system of a (nonprofit?) company that made published scholarly works including books and research papers available to libraries for a fee on subscription basis. I'm of two minds. I, myself, have published several scholarly articles for which I received zero compensation (and book for which I was paid modestly; also very minute compensation when my articles were picked up for an anthology). Mostly, we write these articles (could also maybe count short stories here, too) hoping for wide distribution - so if someone like Swartz came along and said I can make these available to millions, that would be great. That said, I'd want some way to protect my ownership of what I wrote and published; the "creative common" referenced in the film does that to a degree - writers allowing their works online for free but disallowing anyone from using these works for profit. So I think Swartz went over the line, but there's probably way to make more things available to all while assuring that the writers - not the intermediaries - get fair compensation, if any's to be had. (Magazines and distributors deserve a share as well, as long as the writers get what's due them.) That said, Swartz's act harmed nobody, the university (MIT) and the company hacked had no interest in pressing charges - he was simply targeted for his boldness and activism. I have to add, unfortunately, that as a film this documentary had significant problems, in my view. Yes, it's hard to do a doc about a deceased person - not like taking a camera into combat (Virunga) or speaking with the subject - essentially, this is a film composed of archival footage, most of it home movies and clips from TV news shows, and many, many talking heads. I know it's a huge problem for documentarians who've worked months or years on a project - but less is more, and you have to kill your darling - this film could easily have lost 20 minutes and been all the better. And I hate, hate, hate the uptempo music that so many docs use these days and the time lapse photography that shows clouds and traffic rushing by - maybe OK for opening credits (as in House of Cards) but not repeatedly.
Friday, January 30, 2015
Movie without Heroes: A Most Violent Year
A Most Violent Year kept me watching first shot to last, which says
something - it's a well-paced picture about tough, competitive, corrupt guys in the heating-oil business in NYC in the early '80s. Funny to
think of an 80s-set film as a period piece, but I guess it is, and
director J.C. Chandor captures the look and feel of the era - not just
oversized cars (a subtle comment on the cost of heating oil, in fact)
but the derelict buildings on the Brooklyn waterfront, the graffiti
everywhere, the very realistic re-creation of a 1980s graffiti-marked
subway, a cool sequence in which a car chases a hijacked oil truck along
train tracks and through abandoned tunnels. That said, there are many
gaping holes in the story: Story involves suave and dapper heating-oil
dealer Morales (Oscar Isaac) whose trucks are being hijacked and who's
also being investigated by Brooklyn DA as part of review of corruption
in the industry. The first third or more of the movie makes us think
that Isaac is a corrupt gangster who's engaged in a territory war with
rival dealers - the iconography, everything from his look, his
straight-man lawyer, his platinum wife, his ugly new McMansion, and most
of all the way he behaves when making a deal for some property he wants
to buy - make him look and seem like a gangster. Gradually (spoilers
coming) we learn that he's not corrupt, in fact he's the only honest guy
in the industry, although his wife (Jessica Chastain) has been cooking
the books and skimming, unbeknownst to him (or so he says - although it
makes no sense that he helps her hide records from the DA). Similarly,
it makes no sense that the whole story hinges on his refusal to arm his
delivery drivers - I can see that he wouldn't want them to carry guns
for self-defense but he certainly would have provided them some
security. Also never clear why all the dealers in NYC are picking off
only his trucks - do they want to drive him out of business? Why? That's
not how it's done - just keep him out of their territory. Overall, the
problem is that heating wars seems a pretty thin topic and, most of all,
there's nobody for us to root for in this movie: not that the
protagonist has to be a crusader for justice, although that might help,
but we should like him and feel for him esp when his family's under
attack and we just don't or I didn't. By the time the movie shifts gears
and begins to show him as a hero fighting for justice, it was way too
late. And by the way I don't think a bullet from a handgun would pierce
an oil-storage tank, just saying.
Wednesday, January 28, 2015
Each unhappy punk-rock family unhappy in its own way
We Are the Best is a kinda cute Swedish film from 2014 but set in 1981, height of the punk music scene (apparently, who knew?), following three Swedish middle-school girls with, with no talent whatsoever (at least on the part of 2 of them) for a punk band; as w/ most let;s start a band/put on a play movies it builds toward the big night - the performance - but in a rather good twist their performance is not the grand triumph before a cheering crowd that we come to expect from the genre but a show before a tiny crowd that breaks down in chaos; perhaps that's a punk version of triumph. Each happy punk rocker family is alike, but each unhappy punk rocker family is unhappy in its own way - as this movie evinces: one girl has a more or less absent single mom busy in her own romantic/sexual life, one has a kind of nutty dad, one has a strict devout-Christian mom. They find one another through their avowedly terrible music. Like their music, the movie is rough around the edges, a little jumpy at times, perhaps striving for an amateur look w/ a lot of hand-held camera segments. The moment of crisis in the film involves the girls' pursuit of a boys' punk trio, which leaves one of the girls - the lead, really, Bobo - out in the cold as one of the boys didn't show. After some pouting and dramatics, the girls realize they're more important to one another and stay together as a band and as pals rather than break up over boy-troubles. The film's not plot-driven so much as mood-driven. I wouldn't be surprised if an American studio picks it up for a re-make in English, probably in a contemporary setting, probably with more plot twists, too. Hope they don't blow it.
Tuesday, January 27, 2015
Something rotten?: What's wrong with Copenhagen
I watched Copenhagen to get some views of the beautiful city that we recently visited and I wasn't disappointed - in the views. The movie was something else. To me, it seemed like a tepid attempt to capture some of the mood and esprit of Linklater's Before Sunrise series, perhaps mixed with a touch of Jules and Jim (threesomes never work out) - but in my view entirely devoid of the charm and wit that made those films such touchstones. In Copenhagen, two American guys in their late-20s are touring Europe, and the girlfriend of one accompanies them, leading to predictable if uninteresting tensions - doesn't take long for the solo guy to break off and head to C., which as we gradually learn was the purpose for this journey: he has a letter that his late and unbeloved father has written to his father (character's grandfather, whom character has never met or known) that needs to be delivered in person. Our guy meets a girl - cue up "cute meet" - as the waitress spills coffee in his lap - and soon guy and girl are off on a completely movie-like follow-the-clues hunt to track down grandfather. The catch, as guy learns about half-way through the movie but was obvious to me from the start, that the girl is only 14 years old. Ultimately, he shows some more chops by resisting her desire, and his, that he sleep with her, and movie ends with his visit to grandfather - let the old bastard know what a scum he is (he's an ex Nazi, just so you know), boy alone on beach where North Sea and the Atlantic meet - symbolism! - and girl in her middle-school class mooning over snapshots they'd taken on their jaunt. Do you see a sequel coming? All this would be a better movie if the protagonist were in any way likable, but he's scripted and played as the essence of the obnoxious American tourist and the hedonistic 20-something (we know absolutely nothing of his background or home life) who laces just about every sentence with obscenities or vulgarisms. Is that the only way a screenwriter can make his characters sound strong, authentic? Can't we have at least a moment of reflection, insight, wit, or original thought?
Sunday, January 25, 2015
What's gone wrong with TV news: Nightcrawler
There are a bunch of things wrong with Dan Gilroy's but plenty right with it as well and on balance it's a very engaging, scary, and, sadly, accurate account of a deeply disturbed guy who finds his calling as a freelance videographer who sells crime and disaster footage to local LA TV media. We meet Lewis Bloom, played well by Jake Gyllenhaal in a real cast-against-type move, when he's a petty thief lifting scrap metal and manhole covers by night to sell illegally to a junk dealer. When he's caught in the act by a security cop at a freight yard, he punches out the guard and steals his watch - very, very hard to imagine Gyllenhaal doing this, but it sets him up as a crazy young man. The junk business isn't working too well, when by chance he comes across a fatal car accident and watches the crew filming the rescue attempt, and from that point on he builds up his own business - mostly by going way beyond the boundaries of ethics and personal safety to get the best footage (moving a dead body for a better angle, entering the house where there's a home invasion and filming the dead bodies, ultimately failing to disclose vital info he has about a murder in order to set up the arrest of the suspects in a police raid that he films exclusively). What's wrong about the film is how it pushes us way beyond credibility: first of all, who is this guy? He arises just ab ovo, with no back story whatsoever. Now if he's supposed to be an aspiring entrepreneur, no matter how crazy, what's he been doing all this time? It appears that this might be his first night stealing scrap metal - where has he been? Who is he? Second, for the key scenes to work in any conceivable way we have to imagine that somehow he always arrives at the crime or accident scene well before the police and rescue - which is impossible, as he hears about these events from the police scanner. (It can happen, once in a great while - happened to me as a reporter once in fact - but not routinely.) On the plus side, however, in part because he is cast against type and in part because he's a thinking guy and not just a thrill seeker out for kicks, Gyllenhaal's character is very creepy and suspicious - we suspect the worst from him at the outset and we're right. The night footage of LA is consistently beautiful and moody. Most of all, sad to say, the film is dead on about what's happened to TV news over the past 15 years. I'm a bit sick of movies bashing journalists, usually print journalists for that matter, but few if any have taken on this topic and it's very true at real: local TV news no longer covers the news in any serious manner - just death and carnage (if there's no local footage, they'll use national), which to me is one of the great maladies of our culture today - local TV coverage has literally encouraged people to think that world, in fact their community, is a dangerous place full of crime and mayhem and disaster, not a place where almost everyone lives and thinks and loves and aspires and just tries to get on with life. Despite its flaws, a film worth seeing, and even pondering.
Saturday, January 24, 2015
It's too easy to overlook Mike Leigh as a major director
I have to believe that if Mike Leigh films were subtitled and set in Belgium or Rumania, he would be much more widely recognized and appreciated as a serious director of major works of art. Couldn't you take three of his works, about people in London and environs, most of them working class, struggling to get on with and make sense of their lives, and call them a trilogy, and wouldn't they be on a par with the work of the Dardennes brothers, for example? Why not Secrets and Lies, Happy-go-Lucky, and his more recent (2010) Another Year - what a great sequences these three would make, each with a recognizable style and look, but each with its own ethos and mood? Another Year is the darkest of the three for sure, but excellent none the less, and, like many great films (e.g., Rules of the Game), it grows on you and builds in power as it moves along: as if Leigh knows everything about his characters and we learn about the gradually, incrementally - and not through highly dramatic action but by observing their everyday lives, sometimes as they discuss trivia, as most people do, and sometimes in moments of high tension and crisis. Another Year, as title suggests, takes us through a year in the lives of a few people: a 60ish professional couple, Gerry and Tom of good sense and a happy marriage, their adult son who's kind and independent and a bit lonely at least at the outset, and Mary, one of Gerry's co-workers, who is attractive and lively but has a serious not-so-secret drinking problem. Mary's gradual decline over the course of the year is the main narrative thread of the film, and makes this film very sorrowful, right down to the final images when she faces a choice in her life and begins to gain some painful self-knowledge. Along the way, there are many scenes that strike me as very true and recognizable, and Leigh's great skill is to let these scenes just play out at a natural pace, with no flashy technique, no dogmatism, no phony heightened emotions or screaming: especially the excellent scenes late in the film of the funeral and wake in a drab working-class suburb, of the very awkward conversation between Mary and Tom's alcohol-ruined older brother. I think nobody is better than Leigh at getting characters to convey meaning from a glance or a gesture - astonishing how much can "happen" around a kitchen table even when the characters are saying little or speaking in banalities. (Renoir was great at this, too.) Leigh chooses to work w/ actors who are anything but glamorous - the complete opposite of the Hollywood ethos - but on the other hand his life's work is a mixture of these serious interior movies and more conventional period biopics, equally good but quite different (Topsy Turvey, the new Mr. Turner, which I haven't seen), all of which make him hard to categorize and, because of that perhaps, too easy to overlook as a major director.
Sunday, January 18, 2015
Superbad?: The James Brown bio-pic
The James Brown bio-pic Get On Up is such a holy mess and that's such a shame because the music, almost all of it performed by James Brown (and dubbed - I guess that's how they do it - in expertly to Chadwick Boseman's lip synch) that you may want to watch the movie just for the soundtrack, which I did, but good luck trying to keep track of the numerous leaps across time and space, the mad jumping about among different eras in JB's life, for no apparent reason, Boseman's often unintelligible attempts to capture Brown's raspy speaking voice, the weird decision to open with a scene of JB at his lowest ebb and most bizarre public behavior, and ... I could go on but perhaps less said better said. For whatever misguided reason, the crew behind this production decided against a straightforward, chronological musical bio pic, a la the relatively recent Ray Charles of Johnny Cash films, and went for an "art" film approach, like the Bob Dylan disaster (albeit with great soundtrack) I'm Not There. Though the Dylan pic made no sense, at least you could follow it; this weirdly edited version w/ completely unhelpful inter-titles, will defy anyone to keep the eras, the characters, the trends in Brown's career, clear in mind. Boseman does his best, and he dances the part very well; the sidemen are interchangeable (maybe that's the point?) and I know for a fact that the guy playing Maseo Parker looks and sounds nothing like the actual sax player. The women are also interchangeable and expendable - again, maybe that's part of the point, but still - w/ the exception of Brown's estranged mother played well by Viola Davis; Dan Akroyd does his best as JB's manager, but is beset by some totally hackneyed screenwriting. It's frustrating because there was potentially great material in here about the rise to fame of a deeply flawed man, but the film does all that it can to keep the audience distanced from this material. The soundtrack makes it worth watching, or at least worth hearing.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
